- Title: Same-Sex Unions in Premodern Europe
- Author: John Boswell
- ISBN: 9780679432289
- Page: 475
- Format: Hardcover
Both highly praised and intensely controversial, this brilliant book produces dramatic evidence that at one time the Catholic and Eastern Orthodox churches not only sanctioned unions between partners of the same sex, but sanctified them in ceremonies strikingly similar to heterosexual marriage ceremonies.From the Trade Paperback edition.
Recent Comments "Same-Sex Unions in Premodern Europe"
This huge work of scholarship brings to light pre-modern documents concerning heterosexual marriages and same-sex unions. Don't be fooled by the title! Our modern sense of the phrase "same-sex unions" sometimes gets interpreted as "same-sex marriages," which really isn't the case with this book.Sure, there may have been same-sex unions that entailed more than strong friendship or spiritual unity, but reading this book made me realize how diluted our sense of friendship - and how uneducated our k [...]
This book blew my mind. As a historian of Roman religion, early Christianity and the Medieval Church, I never dreamed that the documents he's uncovered would actually exist out there. He's unearthed actual Christian liturgy for same-sex unions, prayers and blessings that couldn't be clearer about giving sanction to the spiritual bond between two people of the same sex the same way the Church does for opposite sex couples. As logical evidence in the current debate, this feels like "game, set, mat [...]
This book is a short tome for those used to reading academic texts that regularly delve into the original Greek, Hebrew, or other source languages. For me, someone who is not used to being steeped in the arcana of ancient text research, this was a tough read. That said, I enjoyed what I got out of it. And the writer was a preeminent scholar at a renowned institution, so he was well within his scholarly milieu in composing this text in the 90s. The biggest revelation here was that not only did sa [...]
I both appreciated and was annoyed by how academic the book was. Boswell made the case that the facts he presented were accurate, but by being so meticulous and detail focused he made a book that was difficult to become immersed in.
Long story short, traditional Roman Catholic practice clearly included same-sex unions of some sort. The evidence seems massive and unmistakable. The author documents the origins of same sex marriage customs, their variety, and the beginnings of a process of repression which seems to date to the fourteenth century. The past may not be as we imagine it.Reading around a bit you can discover that some reviewers question whether these same sex unions included, you know, sex. Some view Boswell skepti [...]
I never thought I'd call a book titled "The Marriage of Likeness: Same-Sex Unions in Premodern Europe" fun, but it was actually fun! I'm a massive nerd, so that probably contributed, but I found it understandable (if you have the concentration to ignore the Greek and Latin footnotes), intelligent, and, at times, very funny. The author injects just enough dry humour at the contrast of the world then and now to make me laugh without distracting me from the point. Though if you're not a massive ner [...]
Before reading this book, I was under the impression that there was no history of same sex unions in premodern europe. It turns out that, in fact, there was enough to fill a very large book with things you'll never learn about in school. Most notable is the discussion of early Christianity and it's view of marriage vs. the marriage beliefs of judaism at the time. I highly recommend this book to anyone who is not already a scholar of the subject.
Fascinating. Marriage is not even close to what you probably thought it was. Especially not Christian concepts of marriage. Those squawking about gay marriage not being traditional (and heck, those on the other side of the debate) should take a gander at this work. Super academic, but accessible and interesting as well.
An incredible work of scholarship that is well researched and cited. This should be on the reading list for anyone who intends to dive into the discussion of the history of Christian marriage, or the same-sex marriage debate.
Wishful thinking at best, Ridiculous and revisionist in all truth.
Impeccably researched. Very academic but provides great historical insight for same gender marriage
Very academic, so a little dry in parts, but fascinating nonetheless.Reading this in the midst of this shitty public "debate" regarding marriage equality in Australia right now has been emotional. All those times we hear homophobes rail against same-sex marriage as not being "traditional" or "the way the Church intended", all that "not Adam and Steve" rubbish - and yet here is the actual history, the well researched facts that show those so-called arguments as the outright lies that they are. Ma [...]
A fascinating work of compelling, erudite scholarship. The eminent Yale historian John Boswell takes on a monumental study of same-sex behavior in premodern Europe, forwarding the controversial claim that both the Eastern Orthodox and Roman Catholic churches not simply permitted but actually performed official marriage rites for same-sex couples prior to the eleventh century.Boswell begins with careful discussions of the terminology and definitions of the words employed in the study, which was b [...]
Make no mistake, this is a scholarly text. It is not fluffy, it is not an easy read. There are numerous inclusions of Greek, Arabic, Latin, Russian and Hebrew in the text, in the footnotes, and, in some cases, entire works in these languages in the appendix. It is a well documented, well researched treatise on Same Sex Unions in Premodern Europe (meaning from the time of Ancient Greek and Roman culture up through the end of the "Dark Ages" in Europe) Truthfully, I had no idea how much I didn't k [...]
Despite a certain amount of enlightenment, I did not enjoy reading this book one bit. It was too academic for me and how could it be anything other than that seeing as it contained 20 pages of ancient Greek text, pages and pages of translated documents and hundreds and hundreds and hundreds of footnotes.A large part of this book was about trying to understand the meaning of words, such as brother or sister, in the context that they were used and attempting to put aside the modern meaning. It als [...]
Superb book altho' too scholarly and too footnoted for the average readerkes the undeniable case that throughout much of Europe--both East and West--same-sex "unions" were widely known and recognized, and often accompanied by formal nuptial ceremonies many cases, with priests as witnesses or officiants. Both the Roman Catholic Church and the Eastern church had formalized liturgies, and several dozen have been found in various archives and libraries. Observers recall witnessing such ceremonies un [...]
John Boswell's meticulously researched book may find its audience limited because of its title. While the author is mostly interested in same-sex marriages the entire first half of the book is necessarily dedicated to an exploration of the origins of marriage in general. I almost found tracing the evolution of marriage more interesting than the same-sex union ceremonies he has uncovered. The roots of marriage (even Christian marriage) are quite different from what one might expect.Boswell goes t [...]
It is a difficult read. It is a book of scholarship written in the language of the serious scholar. This does not mean that the interested reader should not scale this mountain. If one has the discipline and the interest to read through its pages, the rewards are many.The controversies that exist today within the Christian religions in regard to same-sex relationships/ unions/ marriages are not rooted in the history, philosophy or theology of the early Christian church. Records of ceremonies in [...]
This book is not for the faint-of-attention-span. It's highly academic and covers so much more than just same-sex unions. It includes the history of marriage in general, to give readers a reference point for the ceremonies and traditions for same-sex relationships in the time periods. The book had huge sections of footnotes and substantial appendices with documents referred to in the text to aid experts in the field and had many terms left in their original Greek, Latin, Russian and Hebrew with [...]
Thanks to a Towleroad post this book is popping back up into view before it's brought back into 'print' at the end of August. Have been curious when Boswell's book would become a part of the conversation concerning gay marriage again. Remember reading this when it came out 20 years ago. Not exactly what you think it is, but well worth a look. As holy histories go it ain't a Dan Brown page turner, but interesting stuff. Boswell was flogged by other historians for his interpretation of what he fou [...]
I admit that this was a very slow read for me, and clearly was intended for specialists and academics and not for us amateurs. He presents liturgies used for same-sex unions from the Catholic and Orthodox Church for the first thousand years of the church's existence. He companies these with those of other unions and marriages. At the same time, he throws in a history of marriage in premodern Europe in general. The documents are clearly presented, and there are massive amounts of footnotes to hel [...]
This is an extremely dense, well-researched text. The footnotes alone cover anywhere from 1/4 to 3/4 of each page. Boswell goes into extreme detail on the linguistic differences between Greek and Latin, and how the limitations and translations can be interpreted. Because it is so in-depth, it takes much longer to read -- it's a book that requires intense focus -- but it's very much worth it. Boswell clearly knows his scholarship and supports his hypothesis/ conclusion with excellent and well-cit [...]
A lot of the larger picture was lost in an overwhelming amount of attention to detail - need he waste so much time on the concept of brothers and sisters? We got it, Boswell, move on. Is it also necessary to use the original Greek letters in every other sentence? If only the average reader of this academic text were fluent or even functionally literate in ancient Greek. To be sure, Boswell assumed he would be.I feel like this had the potential to be a much more enlightening book. Unforunately, i [...]
Overall fascinating. Who would have thought that Christians had a same-sex marriage ceremony established from Ireland to Armenia? While occasionally dry (as I find most books by historians can be) Boswell's book is full of great stories and insights. A useful book to think about the possibilities for structuring human relationships that fall outside what we would think of as "normative" (and to point out how "normative" is relative!).
Not the most well-written book in the world, but it preceded the current hullabaloo about civil unions for same-sex couples in medieval Europe by oh, at least a few years. Now, whether or not this research actually holds the same kind of water - that I can't tell you off the top of my head. It's an interesting read, though, with a lot of intriguing evidence that does certainly seem to stack up in the right direction.
Although Boswell made some effort to make this accessible to a general audience (in terms of what information was included), it is at heart a scholarly text. Things like heavily academic vocabulary ("misprision" instead of "misunderstand", and "adduced" instead of "caused"), abundant untransilterated Greek and Cyrillic, and copious footnotes make this something of a slog to read. The information itself is interesting, but not presented with the average reader in mind.
This book was simply amazing! Boswell explains everything from the linguistics of the ceremony to the prudish attitudes that made it relatively unknown in the modern world. An excellent example of a thorough study of not only the historical record, but also of the underlying social causes which caused the unfortunate changed in attitude.
While the sections on Ancient Greece and Rome are quite Interesting, it was the later chapters on the early Catholic church that were most eye-opening. The material in the appendix, which includes translations of the ceremonies themselves, is also worth wandering through. Overall, a recommended read for any interested in premodern sexuality and marriage, not just those interested LGBTQ history.
So far, this is by turns intensely dry and intensely interesting. My biggest complaints would have to do with transphobia and other authorial biases. The work itself is well-researched and lucid, with a heavy emphasis on close readings of antiquity texts. Kind of neat.
Boswell has drawn on a wide range of sources from a number of countries which seem to describe same sex unions which were santified and sanction by the church and other legal and administratove bodies. Accessible read supported by very thorough footnotes!
Best Read [John Boswell] ✓ Same-Sex Unions in Premodern Europe || [Nonfiction Book] PDF ☆ 475 John Boswell
Title: Best Read [John Boswell] ✓ Same-Sex Unions in Premodern Europe || [Nonfiction Book] PDF ☆